Thrift Like a Pro: My Best Tips for Secondhand Success

I went thrifting yesterday for the first time in a very long time.

I’ve lost 60 pounds recently (yes, 6-0!), and let me tell you—I am swimming in my old clothes. While I’m still on my weight loss journey and don’t want to invest in a whole new wardrobe just yet, I definitely needed a few things that fit. So we cruised on down to a little place in Hooksett, NH called Corey’s Closet, and whew—it was crowded in there!

A quick sweep of the kitchen section told me there was nothing I needed (or, let’s be honest, could justify dragging home). I’m always on the lookout for stainless steel saucepans and storage containers for my DIY dry mixes, but no luck this round.

Then I popped over to women’s clothing. The section wasn’t huge, but I still found four great tops—one of them from Talbots (can you say score?!). They were marked at $3.50 each, which is already amazing, but when I got to the register? $10 total. That’s less than a fast food combo meal. I’ll absolutely be back.

Whether you’re a seasoned thrifter or thinking about dipping a toe into the secondhand scene, here are my tried-and-true tips for thrifting like a Real Frugalist:

 1. Go In With a List (But Stay Open to Serendipity)

Before you even step foot in the store, jot down a few things you’re on the lookout for—maybe jeans that fit, kids’ snow gear, a set of Pyrex, or a basket for the bathroom clutter.

Having a list keeps you focused and helps avoid that weird moment when you leave with 12 candlesticks and no actual pants.

 2. Know Your Sizes (And Your Family’s Too)

Clothing sizes at thrift stores are… unpredictable. Between vanity sizing, shrinking, and vintage labels, it’s always good to know your actual measurements in inches.

Bring a tape measure and channel your inner tailor. If you’re shopping for kids, jot down their shoe sizes and inseams on your phone before you go.

 3. Look for Brands You Trust

Sure, you’ll see a lot of fast fashion. But there are gems in there. Look for brands that wear well and last—Talbots, Eddie Bauer, LL Bean, Lands’ End, Levi’s, etc.

Even if it’s secondhand, quality is always in style.

 4. Inspect Everything Like You’re on a Mission

• Check for stains, tears, missing buttons, funky smells.
• Spin dishes and pans around for dings and rust.
• Look under shoes for wear patterns.
• Give fabric a stretch test—especially on elastic waistbands.

Better to notice that hole in the armpit before you get home and fall in love.

 5. Grab It While You Can

If you even think you might want something, grab it. Toss it in your cart or sling it over your arm. You can always put it back later, but if you leave it… chances are, it’ll be gone when you come back for it.

Especially true for things like shoes, baskets, or anything remotely adorable.

 6. Be Willing to Walk Out With Nothing

Some days are a bust—and that’s okay.

If you wouldn’t pay full price for it, don’t buy it just because it’s cheap. Walk out with your dignity (and wallet) intact. The next trip might bring the score of the year.

 7. Clean Everything

Wash it, wipe it, soak it in vinegar. Whatever your process, just be sure to give your new-to-you treasures a good scrub.

I like to run clothes through hot water and dry on high heat, especially during flu season. (I’m looking at you, mystery tote bag from aisle four.)

 Bonus Tip: Ask About Discount Days

Some stores offer:

• Half-price tag colors
• Senior or student discounts
• Monthly markdown events
• Punch cards (thrift stores love a loyalty card!)

Don’t be shy—ask the cashier or look for signs when you walk in.

Thrifting is part treasure hunt, part therapy, part money-saving masterclass.

Whether you’re building a wardrobe, stocking your pantry jars, or just browsing for fun, every trip is a new adventure—and today’s trip was a total win. I’ll be heading back to Corey’s Closet with a sharper eye, a little list in hand, and fingers crossed for those saucepans.

What’s your best thrift store score? Drop it in the comments—I want to hear about it!